With the Millennial Tree Cookie update approaching, many players are wondering which Cookies are still worth investing in and which can be deprioritized as we move into late 2025 and beyond.
This guide provides a comprehensive analysis of the best investment options across all rarities, based on current gameplay performance and the latest trailer insights, covering Arena, PvE, and Guild content. It will help you plan your resources strategically and maximize long-term value.
Contents
Ancient Cookies
All five Ancient Cookies have now received their Awakened forms, but not all of them are worth investing in equally.
Recommended Investments
|
Name |
Reason |
|
Pure Vanilla Cookie |
One of the strongest healers in the game right now. He remains highly relevant across Arena and multiple PvE modes. |
|
Hollyberry Cookie |
Currently one of the best tanks in the game. While she was once considered weak months ago, recent changes have pushed her into a top-tier defensive role. |
|
White Lily Cookie |
Continues to see consistent use across Arena and other game modes. |
Not Recommended
- Dark Cacao Cookie
- Golden Cheese Cookie
These two are currently less impactful compared to the other Ancients and are not ideal long-term investments.
Beast Cookies
Beast Cookies remain extremely powerful, but some stand out far more than others in terms of overall value.
Top Priority
|
Name |
Reason |
|
Eternal Sugar Cookie |
The highest-value Beast Cookie overall. She performs exceptionally well in Arena, World Exploration, and various PvE modes, making her the safest and most versatile investment. |
|
Silent Salt Cookie |
Currently very strong and highly effective across multiple areas of the game. |
Still Worth Investing In
|
Name |
Reason |
|
Shadow Milk Cookie |
Necessary for Dragon / Red Velvet Dragon Guild Boss content and should still be invested in. |
|
Burning Spice Cookie |
Excellent for clearing World Exploration and PvE stages. |
|
Mystic Flour Cookie |
Still sees situational use and remains viable. |
Legendary Cookies
Most Legendary Cookies are currently niche, but a few are still worth attention.
|
Recommended |
|
|
Millennial Tree Cookie( Brand-new Cookie) |
He provides strong team sustain through continuous healing, self-cleansing, and shielding. He also offers steady damage and a debuff on key enemies, adding both survival and control to the team. Since he is a newly released Cookie with solid mechanics and strong scaling, it is reasonable to invest in him first. |
|
Wind Archer Cookie |
A strong investment due to his effectiveness in PvE and boss stages. Most importantly, he is confirmed to receive a Crystal Jam, which is expected to bring him back into Arena relevance. |
|
Fire Spirit Cookie |
Performs well in certain situations due to strong damage output. |
|
Situational |
|
|
Sea Fairy Cookie |
Used in Machine God Guild Boss and certain PvE stages, but requires Crystal Jam investment to remain viable. |
|
Not Recommended |
|
|
Pitaya Dragon Cookie |
Still needs a significant buff and is not currently worth investing in. |
Super Epic Cookies
Currently, most Super Epic Cookies are considered outdated. While they can still see occasional use in the Arena or for niche situations, their overall impact is limited. To become competitive again, many of these Cookies would require significant buffs or a complete system revamp.
Recommendation:
Avoid heavy investment in Super Epics for now.
Epic Cookies
Epic Cookies offer the widest range of viable investments, especially for Guild Boss and general PvE content.
|
Recommended |
|
|
Twizzly Gummy Cookie |
Strong Guild Boss performance. |
|
Dark Choco Cookie |
Excellent Crit DMG buffer and Guild Boss staple. |
|
Star Coral Cookie |
One of the best all-around Epic Cookies, used almost everywhere. |
|
Crème Brûlée Cookie |
Extremely strong DPS; can outperform higher-rarity Cookies in many stages. |
|
Rebel Cookie |
Applies elemental weakness, a rare and powerful mechanic |
|
Linzer Cookie |
One of the best support Cookies in the game; highly recommended |
|
Solid / Situational Picks |
|
|
Prune Juice Cookie |
Guild Boss usage |
|
Black Lemonade Cookie |
Strong buffer |
|
Mint Choco Cookie |
Effective at low investment levels |
Some Epic Cookies benefit from Magic Candies, but most do not require maximum investment to perform well.
Special Cookies
Best Specials to Invest In
Marshmallow Bunny Cookie
Cream Ferret Cookie
These two provide the most value among Special Cookies.
Limited Use
Collaboration Specials such as Almond Bar, Glinda, etc.
These can be collected and promoted, but they are unlikely to see long-term usage outside of specific events or Arcade Arena.
Final Thoughts
In summary, by identifying key investment targets and prioritizing versatile Cookies, you can gain an early advantage once the update goes live.
Following the recommendations in this guide ensures that your resource allocation delivers the greatest impact across Arena, Guild, and PvE content, keeping your team strong and adaptable for the challenges ahead.
